Greg Boyd writes compellingly about the catastrophic failure of Christianity. It’s a long article that’s worth reading. Here’s an excerpt (with some parts highlighted in bold letters by me):
A recent Letter to the Editor in my local newspaper went as follows:
When I read letters sent in by Bible thumping Christians telling us how sinful we are and how right they are, how God is on their side, not ours, how God hates gays, liberals and other evil people, I close my eyes for a moment and say a quiet prayer. “I thank thee oh Lord that I am not and never will be a Christian.”
I confess that I am entirely sympathetic to this editorial comment. In my own life, and in the lives of multitudes of people I’ve come across, the best and strongest argument against the truth of Christianity has been the Church…Just recently a young man responded to my invitation to faith by telling me, “I admit I feel the need for a savior, but I honestly just can’t stand Christians!” While he has perhaps not had a well-rounded exposure to Christians, I completely understood where this young man was coming from. Indeed, I’ve spend much of my professional life answering objections to the Christian faith from skeptics, and in all the scholarly tomes I’ve studied I’ve never found an argument against the Christian nearly as compelling as this one.
What makes this situation positively catastrophic is that, according to the New Testament, the Church – the community of those who follow Jesus – is supposed to be the main argument for the truth that Jesus is Lord. By God’s design, the radical love of those who follow Christ is supposed to convince the world that Jesus is for real (Jn13:35; 17:23). Instead, the Church has become the main argument for convincing people he’s not for real. I can’t imagine a greater crisis the Church could possibly face than this one.
Then there’s this:
How did this happen? To ask the question more pointedly, how is it that Jesus was a magnet for prostitutes and tax collectors – the two most despised classes of sinners in Jesus’ day – while the Church repels these types of people, just as the Pharisees did? The answer, I submit, is as inescapable as it is challenging. The Church, as a whole, is simply more like the Pharisees than it is like Jesus.
For those who aren’t familiar with the Bible, the Pharisees were sincerely religious people. Their problem, according to Jesus, was that religion (attending religious services and following rules and rituals) defined them, not intimately knowing and trusting God. And religion, when it comes to the center, is nothing more than a human system, serving selfish interests, and offering (an illusion of) comfort, goodness, and control.
But following Jesus is another matter. Following Jesus means rejecting pretense and embracing reality; it means living with my eyes open and engaged in loving the world, NOT sitting in a closed circle of “believers” trying to meet a minimal standard of grace. It’s not arduous or guilt induced. It’s the result of knowing Love that is so big that we can live without limits in its embrace (without the limits of fear, selfishness, greed, etc.).
This is something that I’ve been mulling over for a long time. That modern Christians resemble the Phasisees of the Bible is not really news in Christian circles. If you’ve spent much time in church, you can probably remember a discussion that went like this: Who do you related with in the passage (from the Bible)? The “tax collectors and sinners” or the “scribes and Pharisees?” (Another variation is the older brother/younger brother in the prodigal son story.) Invariably, many (or most) of the honest, long term Christians confess they identify with the latter group. They express a mild sense of guilt and a resolve to be more humble, and that’s it. They don’t question the very foundation of a religion that has formed them in the mold of those sincere, passionately religious and moral people who most strongly opposed Jesus.
But what a tragedy this is! It’s catastrophic. What is passed off so lightly is the reversal Jesus’ life and message. Somewhere along the way (probably starting long before Constantine declared Christianity the compulary religion of the Roman Empire) sincere people traded in Christ for religion.
Gandhi famously said: “I do so like your Jesus. I don’t like your Christians; they are so unlike your Jesus.” He also said that if Christians lived like Francis of Asisi then all of India would be Christian. But Francis was a radical. Jesus said many radical things, like: “Take up your cross and follow me.” A million Bible studies have established a million rationalizations not to take Jesus’ most radical ideas too literally. Why? Because we don’t believe in the reality behind the words. But Gandhi of all people did.

Greg Boyd concludes that the church of the future will be “religionless.” Jesus not Christianity (as a religion) will be at the center.
I’m not sure how Greg Boyd applies all this concretely, but here’s what I see happening in the world today. People are being attracted to Jesus but not to Christian religion. A flood of people raised in traditional churches are leaving BECAUSE they want to follow Jesus without the religion. Many are creating new structures (like house churches) and simply repackaging their damaged good (we crave comfort and control that much).They are still defined by fear (of getting it wrong) not by love.
Others are casting off religion and tasting freedom in Christ (something the Bible emphatically recommends). They may not get everything right, but here’s what they understand: God’s love is a reality, and it’s huge. They are not concerned about what form their relationships will take, or how to structure gatherings. The Bible says Christ is the Head, and all his followers are like the Body; these people trust the Head can put the Body in order and in motion, so they are resigning from the job (and removing themselves from under the authority of little “heads”).
Their journeys and the turbulence of their departure from religious Christianity may be messy, but who ever said messy is bad? Jesus created a real mess in his day. Really, we can celebrate the mess.
What if the world encountered more and more people living as Jesus did?
Living in fearless love and freedom, not having lives defined by fear?
Trusting and actually surrendering to the Reality encountered in Christ and living it out like Jesus did, rather than attempting to seize control force others to accept “God’s way or the highway” (like the Pharisees did)?
Cartoon source: http://asbojesus.wordpress.com/
9 Comments »